Joseph Buttafuoco
- Early Life and Work
- The Amy Fisher Case
- California Years and Further Legal Trouble
- Personal Life and Public Image
Joey Buttafuoco became one of the most recognizable names in American tabloid news after a private family crisis turned into a national spectacle. A Long Island auto body shop owner, he was thrust into the spotlight in 1992 when teenager Amy Fisher, with whom he had been sexually involved, shot and seriously wounded his wife, Mary Jo. The sensational coverage made him a celebrity, but the story’s lasting weight came from the harm done to his family and from the criminal cases that followed.

Early Life and Work
Joseph “Joey” Buttafuoco was born on 11 March 1956 and grew up on Long Island, New York. Before becoming a fixture in national headlines, he worked as an auto mechanic and ran an auto body repair business. In the early 1990s, he was married to Mary Jo, his high school sweetheart, and they had two children.

The Amy Fisher Case
In May 1992, 17-year-old Amy Fisher went to the Buttafuoco home in Massapequa and shot Mary Jo in the face. Mary Jo survived, but suffered severe and lasting injuries. The attack followed Fisher’s sexual relationship with Joey, which had begun when she was 16. At first, he denied having sex with her. The case drew intense tabloid attention, and the press branded Fisher the “Long Island Lolita,” a label that turned a serious crime and a teenager’s exploitation into lurid entertainment.

In 1993, Buttafuoco pleaded guilty to third-degree rape for having sex with Fisher while she was underage. He was sentenced to six months in jail and five years of probation, and served about four months before his release in March 1994. His conviction punctured the denials that had surrounded the case and kept the family under public scrutiny long after the shooting.

The story’s reach extended well beyond the courtroom. Interviews, television specials and several made-for-TV dramatizations followed, making the case a landmark example of early 1990s tabloid culture. Buttafuoco and Mary Jo remained together for years after the shooting, later moving with their children to California. They separated in 2000, and Mary Jo filed for divorce in 2003 after 26 years of marriage.
California Years and Further Legal Trouble
After relocating to California, Buttafuoco tried to move into entertainment. He pursued acting and hosted a short-lived cable-access talk show, while continuing to work in the auto repair trade. His notoriety opened doors to media appearances, but also meant that his public identity remained tied to the Fisher case.
In 1995, he pleaded no contest to soliciting prostitution from an undercover officer in Los Angeles. The incident violated his New York probation, and he received additional jail time. Later, he became involved in a California insurance fraud case connected to an auto body shop he co-owned. In 2004, he pleaded guilty to insurance fraud and was sentenced to a year in jail, five years of probation and restitution. The court also barred him for life from working in California’s auto body business.
In a separate case, Buttafuoco pleaded no contest in 2006 to illegally possessing ammunition as a convicted felon. He began serving a one-year sentence in 2007 and was released after three months.
Personal Life and Public Image
Mary Jo’s recovery and the couple’s strained marriage were repeatedly revisited in interviews and television programs. Their children, Jessica and Paul, also grew up in the shadow of a story that had been turned into public spectacle. The continued attention often centered on the sensational triangle, while Mary Jo’s experience as a survivor and the family’s private consequences received less attention at the time.
Buttafuoco’s public image has remained shaped by the contrast between his ordinary trade as a mechanic and the extraordinary media storm around his family. His later attempts at acting and broadcasting never displaced that association. The case is still discussed as a defining tabloid story of its era, while the legal record—his guilty plea in the rape case and later convictions—remains central to any account of his life.
USA




