Mary Jo Buttafuoco

Mary Jo Buttafuoco

American author and speaker whose life story centers on recovery from a highly publicized 1992 shooting.
Date of Birth: 01.01.1956
Country: USA
  1. Early Life
  2. Survival and Recovery
  3. Author and Advocate
  4. Reclaiming Her Story

Early Life

Mary Jo Buttafuoco was born Mary Jo Connery on May 15, 1955, in New York. Before the event that brought her into national headlines, she led a private life on Long Island as a wife and mother of two. In May 1992, her life changed abruptly when 17-year-old Amy Fisher came to the family home in Massapequa and shot her after confronting her about an affair with her husband, Joey Buttafuoco.

Survival and Recovery

Buttafuoco survived the attack, but the injuries left lasting effects, including partial facial paralysis and hearing loss in one ear. The case drew intense tabloid coverage, much of it focused on Fisher and the affair. Buttafuoco later said that the public story often left little room for her own experience as a survivor, a mother, and a person rebuilding her life.

She remained married for several years after the shooting, then eventually left the relationship and divorced in 2003. In interviews, she has spoken about the physical and emotional work of recovery, and about trying to understand the decisions she made in the years after the attack. Her account also offers a view of the family upheaval and media attention that followed the case, beyond its sensational headlines.

Author and Advocate

In 2009, Buttafuoco published the memoir Getting It Through My Thick Skull: Why I Stayed, What I Learned, and What Millions of People Involved with Sociopaths Need to Know. The book recounts her life before and after the shooting and reflects on why she stayed in her marriage, the warning signs she says she missed, and the lessons she hoped other people might take from her experience. She later spoke publicly about unhealthy relationships and the long-term effects of gun violence.

Reclaiming Her Story

For many years, her experience had been retold through television dramatizations, interviews, and coverage that cast her mainly as the victim in a tabloid scandal. In 2026, she narrated I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco, a Lifetime film that presented the events from her own point of view. Her story is one of survival and recovery, but also of taking back the narrative of a life that had been defined in public by a single traumatic moment.